neur.ro

Circle of competence

type: mental model · origin: practice · evidence: not directly tested · themes: choices and costs

Claim assessed: You make better decisions if you stay in the areas you can evaluate correctly and know their boundaries.

Published , updated · how we work

In short

Your circle of competence is the area in which you can actually evaluate things correctly. The idea comes from the investor Warren Buffett: you don’t have to know about everything, just exactly where your knowledge ends, and decide within that boundary. It is a practical rule, not a scientifically tested result. The related research, on how well we judge our own level, is discussed, with its critiques, in the entry on the Dunning-Kruger effect.

What it says

The source. In his 1996 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders, Buffett gave ordinary investors a few pieces of advice. The first was that most of them would do best to buy a low-cost index fund, which beats the net results of most professionals. To those who still want to pick their own stocks, he said that intelligent investing is not complex, though that doesn’t mean it is easy. An investor only needs to be able to correctly evaluate certain businesses of their own choosing: “You don’t have to be an expert on every company, or even many. You only have to be able to evaluate companies within your circle of competence. The size of that circle is not very important; knowing its boundaries, however, is vital.”

How we read it as a general rule. Taken out of investing, the idea has two parts. First, competence is local, not general, and someone very good in one area can be a beginner in the next. Second, the boundary matters more than the size. Big mistakes come less from what you don’t know than from not noticing when you have gone past what you know. This generalisation is ours; Buffett was talking about picking stocks.

A circle represents the area in which you can evaluate correctly. Inside, decisions are safe. At the boundary, mistakes easily go unnoticed. Outside, you choose between giving up, learning or asking for help. The size of the circle matters little; knowing its boundary matters a lot. The circle and its boundary after Buffett's 1996 letter you can judge correctly Inside you decide on what you know At the boundary mistakes go unnoticed Outside give up, learn or ask for help The size of the circle matters little; knowing its boundary matters a lot.
Conceptual diagram. The three zones are our reading of Buffett's idea, not research findings.

What research says. The hard part of the rule is seeing your own boundaries, and studies on self-assessment show that people judge their level relative to others imperfectly. How big the problem is and where it comes from is still debated; the details are in the entry on the Dunning-Kruger effect. We found no studies that directly test whether people who respect a circle of competence make better decisions.

Example

A programmer who is good at web applications starts running their own email server. They don’t know what they don’t know: DNS records, address reputation, anti-spam rules. Everything seems to work, until their messages land in spam. The problem isn’t that they don’t understand email servers, but that they didn’t notice they had left the circle. The example is an illustration, not a study cited here.

How to apply it

The steps below are a practical approach we propose, not a tested method.

  1. Draw the circle explicitly. Write down the areas where you have verifiable results, not just experience or interest.
  2. Check the boundary with outside feedback, not with a feeling. Write down beforehand what you expect to happen, then compare with the actual result.
  3. Slow down at the edge. New or unusual decisions, even in a familiar area, need extra checks.
  4. Outside the circle, choose deliberately. You can give up, learn until you are inside the circle, or borrow the competence of someone inside it.
  5. With money, consider the simple option. For most investors, Buffett recommended a low-cost index fund.

Limits and nuances

Sources

See also: Dunning-Kruger effect, Planning fallacy, Via negativa