neur.ro

Implementation intentions

type: technique · origin: study · evidence: strong · themes: habits and self-control

Claim assessed: A plan of the form ‘if X happens, I do Y’ raises the chance of moving from intention to action.

Published , updated · how we work

In short

Wanting something (“I want to exercise”) doesn’t guarantee that you will actually do it. The psychologist Peter Gollwitzer proposed an extra step: you link, in advance, a concrete situation to a concrete action, in the format “if situation X arises, then I will do Y”. A plan like this is called an implementation intention. A 2006 meta-analysis (a study that gathers and combines the results of many studies), covering 94 independent comparisons (in effect, experiments), found a medium-to-large effect on goal attainment (Gollwitzer & Sheeran, 2006). A more recent meta-analysis, covering 642 independent comparisons, confirms that the method works and shows when it works best. After correcting for unpublished studies, however, its effect is much smaller: d = 0.15 (Sheeran et al., 2024).

What it says

Goal versus plan. Gollwitzer distinguishes between two things:

The second does not replace the first. It is a plan built in service of it (Gollwitzer, 1999; Gollwitzer & Sheeran, 2006).

Why it might work. The central idea in Gollwitzer (1999) is that, through this kind of plan, the person “delegates” control of the action to a situation they have anticipated. When the situation arises, the behaviour starts more easily, almost automatically, without fresh deliberation. The 2006 meta-analysis found strong support for two proposed processes:

From goal intention to the plan “if X, then Y”: when situation X arises, action Y starts almost automatically. Goal intention what you want: “I intend to reach Z” Plan: “if X, then Y” when, where and how you act Situation X arises easier to notice, comes to mind faster Action Y starts almost automatically, without fresh deliberation The plan delegates control to the situation Gollwitzer (1999); Gollwitzer & Sheeran (2006)
The goal says what you want; the plan says when and how you act. The last two boxes are the two mechanisms supported by the 2006 meta-analysis.

How big the effect is. Gollwitzer and Sheeran (2006) gathered 94 independent comparisons. The average effect on goal attainment was d = 0.65. The d index shows how large the difference is between the group that made a plan and the comparison group. By Cohen’s conventions, 0.2 means a small effect, 0.5 a medium one and 0.8 a large one, so 0.65 lies between medium and large. The effect appeared:

What remains after correction. The 2024 meta-analysis by Sheeran, Listrom and Gollwitzer covered 642 independent comparisons, gathered from studies published between 1994 and 2019. Forming implementation intentions was effective for outcomes involving thoughts, emotions and behaviour, with effects between d = 0.27 and d = 0.66, depending on the type of outcome. The simple average was d = 0.36. The authors found strong signs of selective publication, though: small studies with positive results were overrepresented. Corrected with a robust Bayesian method, the data gave very strong evidence that the effect exists, but the estimate fell to d = 0.15, with an interval of 0.08–0.22. The authors’ conclusion: the effect is robust, but small by the usual conventions and highly variable from one study to another.

The effect size of implementation intentions: 0.65 in the 2006 meta-analysis, 0.36 as the simple average in the 2024 meta-analysis and 0.15 after correcting for unpublished studies. Smaller after correction effect size (d) 2006, 94 tests 0.65 2024, simple average 0.36 2024, corrected 0.15 The effect remains clear after correction, but it is small and varies a lot between studies.
Gollwitzer and Sheeran (2006), from the abstract; Sheeran, Listrom and Gollwitzer (2024), with the authors' correction using a robust Bayesian method.

Example

An example cited by Gollwitzer (1999) comes from a study by Orbell, Hodgkins and Sheeran (1997). Women who had set out to do a breast self-examination in the following month were asked to write down where and when they would do it. Among participants who had a strong intention to do the self-examination, all of them (100%) did it if they had also formed an implementation intention. Without the extra plan, only 53% did it. The figures are taken from Gollwitzer (1999); we have not checked them in the original article.

How to apply it

The basic format is: “If [concrete situation], then [concrete action].” The situation should be something you will recognise at the right moment, such as a time, a place or a point in a routine. The action should be something you can start right away.

Examples (illustrative, built for this text):

What the sources say about making the plan more effective:

Limits and nuances

Sources

See also: Delayed gratification, Ego depletion, Habit formation, Mental contrasting (WOOP), Planning fallacy, Spacing and retrieval practice