Diminishing returns
Claim assessed: Each extra unit of a good thing brings less than the one before.
Published , updated · how we work
In short
Diminishing returns means that, past a certain point, each extra unit of something (money, time, effort, another slice of cake) brings a smaller and smaller gain. It does not mean the benefit disappears, only that each additional step counts for less than the one before. The best-studied example in psychology is the link between income and well-being: the same amount matters a lot to someone on a low income and little to someone on a high one.
What it says
The old idea. In 1738, the mathematician Daniel Bernoulli proposed that a small increase in wealth brings a gain in utility inversely proportional to the wealth already held. In other words, the same amount matters more to a poor person than to a rich one. Mathematically, his hypothesis leads to utility that grows with the logarithm of wealth: each doubling brings the same gain.
What the data show about income and happiness. Three large studies, all published in PNAS, contradicted each other and then made peace:
- Kahneman and Deaton (2010) analysed more than 450,000 responses to a daily Gallup survey in the US. Overall life evaluation rose steadily with log income. Day-to-day emotional well-being rose too, but made no further progress beyond an annual income of about $75,000.
- Killingsworth (2021) used 1,725,994 real-time reports, sent from mobile phones at randomly chosen moments, from 33,391 employed US adults. He found that both experienced and evaluative well-being rise linearly with log income, as steeply above $80,000 as below it. No plateau.
- Killingsworth, Kahneman and Mellers (2023) worked together, in an “adversarial collaboration”, to resolve the conflict. Reanalysing the 2021 data, they found that the plateau exists, but only among the least happy people. For the unhappiest 15%, happiness rises quickly up to $100,000 and then barely at all. For everyone else, it keeps rising with log income, and among the happiest it even accelerates. The authors also explain why the 2010 study overstated the plateau: its yes/no questions could not distinguish between degrees of happiness.
Where the diminishing returns are. “Linear in log income” means exactly diminishing returns per dollar. Going from $25,000 to $50,000 brings roughly the same gain in well-being as going from $100,000 to $200,000, although the second takes four times as much money.
Example
An example built for this text: a raise of 500 a month. For someone earning 3,000, it is a one-sixth increase and is felt every month. For someone earning 30,000, it barely registers. The studies above suggest that the two would need very different amounts (proportional to their incomes) for a comparable gain in well-being.
The same pattern appears, as an analogy, outside money too: the first hours of studying for an exam bring a lot, the last ones less. The tenth review read before a purchase rarely changes the decision.
How to apply it
The steps below are a practical approach we propose. The studies cited measure the link between income and well-being; they don’t test this advice.
- Think in proportions, not amounts. When weighing a gain or an expense, ask what share it is of what you already have, not just how much it is.
- Look for the point where one more step brings little. In projects, in preparation, in the search for the “perfect option”: if the last effort changed the result only a little, the next one will probably change it even less. See the entry on maximizing and satisficing.
- Move the resource to where it is still scarce. If more of one thing brings less and less, the same resource may bring more elsewhere. It is the same logic behind the Pareto principle.
- Don’t confuse “diminishing” with “zero”. In Killingsworth’s data, for most people more money still goes with more happiness. It’s just that each doubling brings the same step, not each extra amount.
Limits and nuances
- The data are correlational. The studies compare people with different incomes. They don’t show what happens to the happiness of the same person when their income rises, nor do they prove that money causes the difference.
- US only. All three studies use data from the United States. The dollar thresholds ($75,000, $100,000) don’t carry over directly to other countries or other years.
- “Happiness” means different things. Kahneman and Deaton separate life evaluation from everyday emotions, and the two relate to income differently. The result depends on what you measure and how.
- The average hides differences. The 2023 collaboration shows that the pattern isn’t the same for everyone: a plateau for the unhappiest, acceleration for the happiest. A single average curve can mislead.
- Extending it to other domains is an analogy. The examples about studying or reviews are not tested in the sources cited.
- What we read. We read in full the studies by Killingsworth (2021) and Killingsworth, Kahneman and Mellers (2023), from PubMed Central. Of Kahneman and Deaton (2010), we read the abstract, which contains all the figures cited here. We could not read the English translation of Bernoulli’s work: we present his idea as it is widely cited in the specialist literature.
- Revised on 7 October 2026. We removed an example attributed to Bernoulli, which we could not check in the text, clarified how the 2021 data were collected and added this list.
Sources
- Daniel Bernoulli (1738). Exposition of a New Theory on the Measurement of Risk (English translation, 1954)
- Daniel Kahneman, Angus Deaton (2010). High income improves evaluation of life but not emotional well-being
- Matthew A. Killingsworth (2021). Experienced well-being rises with income, even above $75,000 per year
- Matthew A. Killingsworth, Daniel Kahneman, Barbara Mellers (2023). Income and emotional well-being: A conflict resolved
See also: Maximizing vs satisficing, Pareto principle, Via negativa