neur.ro

Maximizing vs satisficing

type: mental model · origin: study · evidence: contested · themes: choices and costs

Claim assessed: People who look for the best option are less satisfied than those who choose what is good enough.

Published , updated · how we work

In short

When you choose something, you can look for the best possible option, or you can stop at the first one that is good enough. Herbert Simon, who worked across economics and psychology, called the second strategy satisficing. Barry Schwartz and his colleagues later showed that people differ in which strategy they prefer. On average, those who maximize report less satisfaction and more regret. In one study, they landed higher salaries in their first job but were less happy with it.

What it says

Simon’s idea. In 1956, Simon wrote that organisms adapt well enough to “satisfice”; they do not, in general, “optimize”. Schwartz et al. (2002) summarise the idea this way: because of the limits on how we process information, people cannot find the best option among all of them. All they need is a scale on which to rate the options and a threshold of acceptability: they evaluate options one by one, and the first one that passes the threshold is chosen.

Eight options seen one after another. The satisficer stops at the third, the first one above the bar. The maximizer evaluates all eight and picks the sixth, the best one. Options, in the order they appear the “good enough” bar stop the best Satisficing: stops at the first above the bar Maximizing: compares them all more effort, more forgone options to regret
An illustration of the two strategies, not data from a study. Satisficing means having a bar and choosing the first option that clears it.

From strategy to trait. Schwartz et al. (2002) started from Simon but asked something else: do people differ in how much they want to maximize? The authors put the difference this way: maximizers want the best possible result, satisficers want a result good enough to meet some criterion. They built a questionnaire, the Maximization Scale, and gave it to seven samples, 1,747 participants in total (students and community adults).

What they found, according to the article:

Better objectively, worse subjectively. Iyengar, Wells and Schwartz (2006) measured students’ maximizing tendency in the fall of their final year, then followed them through the year as they looked for a first job. Students with a strong maximizing tendency landed starting salaries 20% higher. Yet they were less satisfied with the job they took and experienced more negative emotions throughout the search. The authors link the gap to two things: maximizers relied more on external sources of information and fixated more on the options they had and the ones they did not choose.

Example

The examples below are built for this text. You’re looking for something to watch on TV, with hundreds of channels to choose from. The maximizer flips through every channel to be sure of picking the best show. The satisficer stops at the first one that seems good enough.

The same goes for shopping for a washing machine. The maximizing version: you compare every model in three shops, read dozens of reviews, put the decision off for two weeks and, after buying, wonder whether the model you passed over was better. The satisficing version: you set three criteria in advance (capacity, energy use, maximum price) and buy the first model that meets all of them.

How to apply it

The suggestions below extrapolate from the studies cited, which are correlational or run in the lab. They did not test this advice.

Limits and nuances

Sources

See also: Diminishing returns, Opportunity cost, Pareto principle