neur.ro

Opportunity cost

type: mental model · origin: study · evidence: strong · themes: choices and costs

Claim assessed: People don't always think on their own about the alternative they give up, and a reminder of it changes their choice.

Published , updated · how we work

In short

Every choice means giving something else up: money, time or attention put in one place can’t be put in another. Opportunity cost is the value of the best alternative you give up. The idea comes from economics. Decision psychology has shown that people often neglect this cost: when they are reminded what else they could do with the money, they buy less often. A 2023 meta-analysis confirms the effect, but shows that it is much smaller than in the first study.

What it says

Opportunity cost neglect. Frederick, Novemsky, Wang, Dhar and Nowlis (2009) start from the observation that, to take opportunity cost into account, you have to actively imagine the alternatives you give up. Their conclusion is that people often don’t. They tested the idea with minimal changes of wording that add no new information. In their first study, participants imagined they could buy a DVD for $14.99. For half of them, the option to decline was “Not buy”. For the other half it was “Keep the $14.99 for other purchases”, which means exactly the same thing. With the first wording, 75% said they would buy; with the second, 55%. In another study, choosing between two iPod models, the share of the cheaper one roughly doubled when the price difference was described as “leaving you $100 in cash”.

The logic is simple: if people thought of the alternatives on their own, such rewordings would have no effect. According to the article’s abstract, the effects also appeared under conditions that encouraged participants to think harder, and sensitivity to these reminders depends on each person’s attitude to spending.

How big the effect really is. Maguire, Persson and Tinghög (2023) ran a preregistered meta-analysis, meaning the method was announced in advance. They gathered 39 experiments from 12 studies, published and unpublished, with 12,093 participants. The average effect was d = 0.22, compared with 0.45–0.85 in the studies by Frederick et al. The d index shows how large the difference between groups is; by Cohen’s conventions, 0.2 means a small effect. The 2009 experiments turned out to differ from all the others and accounted for the signs of selective publication. Without them, the tests for selective publication were no longer significant, and the effect fell to d = 0.16, with an interval of 0.10–0.22. The authors’ conclusion: the phenomenon is robust, but small.

Frederick et al. (2009): 75% say they would buy the DVD when declining is worded "Not buy", but 55% when it is worded "Keep the $14.99 for other purchases". Effect size: between 0.45 and 0.85 in the 2009 studies, 0.22 in the 2023 meta-analysis and 0.16 without the 2009 studies. Study 1A: a $14.99 DVD how many would buy, by how declining is worded "Not buy" 75% "Keep the $14.99 for other purchases" 55% How big the effect is effect size (d) Frederick et al., 2009 0.45–0.85 meta-analysis, 39 tests 0.22 without the 2009 studies 0.16 The effect holds after correction, but it is several times smaller than in the first study.
The Study 1A percentages and the 0.45–0.85 range are as reported by Maguire et al. (2023) about Frederick et al. (2009). Coloured top bar: the wording that mentions what else the money could be used for.

Even economists disagree. Ferraro and Taylor (2005) put a question from an introductory economics textbook to economists with PhDs and to PhD students at the 2005 annual meeting of the Allied Social Science Associations (ASSA). You won a free ticket, with no resale value, to an Eric Clapton concert. Bob Dylan is playing the same night, and a ticket to see him costs $40, although you would be willing to pay up to $50. What is the opportunity cost of the Clapton concert? The answer considered correct is “$10”, that is, 50 minus 40. Only 43 of 199 respondents (21.6%) chose it, and the answers were split almost evenly across the four options. Potter and Sanders (2012) challenged the conclusion: depending on how you account for the cost, they argue, every one of the answers can be defended, and the question doesn’t measure how well economists understand the concept. The practical lesson is that, although the idea is simple, the concrete calculation depends on what exactly you count as “the alternative”.

Example

The examples below are built for this text, not taken from studies.

You are choosing between two phones, one for 4,000 lei and one for 2,800. The question “is the difference worth it?” stays abstract. The question “do I want the expensive phone, or the cheap one plus a 1,200-lei weekend in the mountains?” makes the alternative concrete, and the decision may change.

A free evening can be spent scrolling on your phone, and it seems to cost nothing. The opportunity cost is the best thing you would otherwise have done: a book, a walk, a conversation with someone close.

How to apply it

The steps below are a practical approach we propose. The only thing tested in studies is that spelling out the alternative changes the choice.

  1. Put the alternative into words. Instead of “do I buy or not?”, ask yourself “do I buy this or keep the money for X?”, where X is something concrete you actually want. It is the same change of wording that changed choices in the studies.
  2. Translate the price difference into something else. When choosing between an expensive and a cheap option, say the difference out loud: “the cheaper option leaves me 300 lei for…”.
  3. Apply it to time too. An hour spent in a pointless meeting is an hour that can’t go into something else. Opportunity cost isn’t measured only in money.
  4. Don’t turn everything into a calculation. Not every small decision is worth analysing. See the entry on maximizing and satisficing.

Limits and nuances

Sources

See also: Cost of action vs cost of inaction, Maximizing vs satisficing, Sunk cost